The only reason you guys are good in keyboard, is because you practiced it.
This is becoming redudant, no one is arguing keyboard or pad are bad choices, there is someone out there that can beat me on stick, with those two mediums, however if we take into consideration. Stick has the highest potential out of all 3. I am scrub, and I can pull any move without messing up on the stick, pro players will own your soul, and if we get equal talanted, which is impossible but lets pretend or use close examples, like top tier japanese players. Any pad or keyboard player would lose.
Bet on it.
Its all about ergonomics, range of motion, reflex speed, a joystick makes all those easer to do. Keyboard will fatigue you, despite being accurate, its also not ergonomic,
a pad is sometimes somewhat ergonomic but by limited and forcing you to grip the pad, your already using tension, and fatiguing the player.
A stick needs small flicks, and two hands are being used, much more comfortable, once and if netplay becomes stable and quick, and I practice this game enough, Ill open challenge any keyboard or pad player to a 1 on 1.
Believe it